Mystic Market East

The sandwiches are great but the wait is ridiculous. Avoid this place. Just know that if you order online you go to the back of the line versus people who are in the store so you might wait an hour while someone else orders 40 minutes after you waits just 10 minutes. This is not posted on the website. Don't bother coming here, find some other place with decent sandwiches.

Can always get basically the same thing. Which is nice sometimes. But we have waited a ridiculously long time for two sandwiches before. But usually pretty decent timing and good service. Great chicken salad and other premade salads. And great hot sandwiches. Also try their frozen meat lasagna. It's my favorite freezer to stove meal.

We had this awesome butterscotch cheesecake at a restaurant and was told it was made at Mystic Market East. We were so excited to find out we could buy it not at the restaurant. So we were excited and couldn't wait to go. We arrive and our excitement quickly fizzled when ny boyfriend's wheelchair couldn't access the market. Absolutely nothing worse than a place not accessible to everyone. So he had to wait in the car while I went in. So disappointing.but for able bodied no disabilities people it had a coffee bar, dessert section, prepared meal section, deli and variety of different kinds of salad,pasta salad etc... Also had a little section of grocery items. I grabbed the butterscotch cheesecake but it looks nothing like the cheesecake at the restaurant and because it has choc and im allergic I couldn't even get a piece. I had to settle for vanilla cheesecake with cherries. Just disappointed but it is what it is. Went on a Saturday and the traffic was crazy and the market was crazy as well. My new favorite grinder the Jammin turkey. Seriously so delicious. It comes on multi grain bread but I have it as a grinder. My favorite place for dessert and now jammin turkey

This place usually deserves a 10 but not today. The service was great and they are very efficient. I had my roast beef on a French baguette and the roast beef is great as well as the toppings but the bread definitely was not fresh, it was chewy and not very appetizing. That’s the first time I had some thing that I wasn’t thrilled with here. choose a different bread

The food is usually excellent, no matter whether it’s a sandwich or soup or an already made entrée. My partner and I have noticed the bread has been very stale and not very good so I’m wondering what could Mystic market do to make sure their bread is fresh because that really makes the sandwich special when the bread is fresh!! PLEASE DO!!! yes, the wait is sometimes really hard , but I think it’s better when you go off the normal times in between breakfast lunch and later, dinner definitely helps!! We like the Mystic market in old Saybrook Connecticut the best. They really have there act together, it and I don’t know why they can’t do the same here in Mystic??? Especially A town that is always booming. Tina Catanzaro